You are building a structured data-extraction system using Claude.

Option C converts an empirically validated source hierarchy into an explicit extraction rule. The downstream contract requires one battery_capacity value, and historical analysis establishes that the detailed specifications table is substantially more reliable than the summary section. Claude should therefore be instructed to inspect all occurrences, detect conflicts, and select the detailed-table value when the two locations disagree.

Anthropic’s prompting guidance emphasizes clear, direct instructions, relevant context, and explicit decision rules when order or completeness matters. Providing the reason for the precedence rule also helps the model generalize it to comparable specification conflicts. Option A preserves every value but transfers a known and repeatable decision into downstream systems, unnecessarily changing the schema. Option B rejects approximately 15% of otherwise processable documents even though a reliable precedence policy is available. Option D creates a costly manual-review queue for conflicts that can usually be resolved deterministically. The extraction system should still retain source quotations or locations in internal provenance metadata when auditability matters, but the output field should follow the established detailed-table precedence. Anthropic prompting best practices