Where an employee has contributed more CPP than required for the year, the excess employee contribution is ultimately refunded or credited through the individual's income tax return.
CRA specifically provides for CPP overpayments to be calculated on the applicable Schedule 8 or interprovincial CPP/QPP form. The excess is reported on the individual's tax return, and CRA will either refund it or apply it against another balance owing.
An employer that discovers an over-deduction during the same year should generally correct its payroll records and reimburse the employee directly. However, where the overpayment remains on the T4 and has not been reimbursed, CRA credits the excess when the employee files the personal return.
The excess is not transferred to an RRSP, nor is it automatically carried forward against the employee's CPP obligation for the next calendar year. CPP contribution calculations operate on an annual basis.
Option A is also incorrect because repayment of the employee's own excessive CPP deduction is not a taxable employment benefit.
Accordingly, within the circumstances presented in the question, option D is the correct treatment.
FPII reference/topic: Retirement Planning — Canada Pension Plan; maximum pensionable earnings; employee contributions; CPP overpayments and refunds.
===============