You are a member of OACETT, a principal in XYZ Company and also a member...

1. What is Alternative G1?

The scenario describesa professional working on a project for their employerwhile alsobeing offered outside work related to the same field.

This createsa conflict of interest and a potential confidentiality violation.

2. Ethical Problems with Alternative G1

Confidentiality Breach:

The employeehas access to confidential company information.

Using this knowledgefor a personal project or another company is unethical and potentially illegal.

Conflict of Interest:

Accepting a competing contractcreates divided loyalties.

The professionalmay prioritize personal financial gain over their employer’s interests.

Employer-Employee Relationship:

Professionals owe aduty of loyalty to their employer.

Performing workfor a competitorisboth unethical and potentially grounds for dismissal.

3. Real-World Example: Ethical Violations in Competing Work

Scenario:

An engineerdesigning a proprietary control systemforCompany Ais approached byCompany B(a competitor) to work on asimilar system on their own time.

Even if they don’t directly copy their employer’s work, they are using knowledge gained from their employer’s project.

This is unethical and could lead to legal action.

4. Why Option A is Correct:

Accepting outside work in competition with an employer is unethical.

It jeopardizes both company interests and professional integrity.

5. Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

B (Ethically acceptable)– Incorrect becauseit violates confidentiality and creates a conflict of interest.

C (Not dealing with fairness, courtesy, or good faith)– This does not fully addressthe confidentiality and conflict-of-interest issues.

D (Contractually and ethically correct)– Incorrect becauseit is neither contractually nor ethically sound.