An offer of $569,000 is verbally accepted by a seller.

Under Massachusetts law and the Statute of Frauds (M.G.L. c. 259), all contracts for the sale of real property must be in writing and signed to be enforceable. A verbal acceptance of an offer does not create a binding real estate contract. Therefore, when the seller verbally accepted the first offer of $569,000, no enforceable agreement was formed.

Later, when the seller accepted the $589,000 offer in writing, that acceptance created the first legally binding contract because it was in writing and signed. The first buyer cannot compel the seller to sell to them, as there was no enforceable written agreement.

Thus, the first buyer is not entitled to purchase the property. Only the second, written offer created enforceable contractual rights.