A company manages a data lake in an Amazon S3 bucket that numerous applications access...

Understanding the Requirement: The company wants to restrict each application to its specific prefix in an S3 bucket and have granular control over the objects under each prefix.

Analysis of Options:

Dedicated S3 Access Points: Provides a scalable and flexible way to manage access to S3 buckets, allowing specific policies to be attached to each access point, thereby controlling access at the prefix level.

S3 Batch Operations: Suitable for large-scale changes but involves more operational overhead and does not dynamically control future access.

Replication to new S3 buckets: Involves unnecessary duplication of data and increased storage costs, and operational overhead for managing multiple buckets.

Combination of replication and access points: Adds unnecessary complexity and overhead compared to using access points directly.

Best Solution:

Dedicated S3 Access Points: This provides the least operational overhead while meeting the requirements for prefix-level access control and granular management.