A website runs on Amazon EC2 behind an ALB with Amazon CloudFront in front.

The most effective and AWS-recommended way to mitigate unwanted traffic at the edge is to use AWS WAF integrated with CloudFront. Option D allows the architect to block or throttle malicious traffic before it reaches the ALB or EC2 instances.

Rate-based rules automatically block IP addresses that exceed a defined request threshold, making them ideal for mitigating abusive traffic patterns. This reduces load on backend resources and improves performance for legitimate users.

Options A, B, and C are less effective or introduce unnecessary cost and complexity. Shield does not provide granular rate control, Auto Scaling increases cost, and NACLs are difficult to manage dynamically.

Therefore, D is the correct and most secure solution.